1. PERSONAL PROTECTION ORDERS
Personal protection orders (formerly restraining orders)
(pursuant to MCLA 600.2950) are civil
orders of the circuit court designed to protect domestic violence
victims. The victim must
demonstrate to the circuit court that there is reasonable cause to
believe that the person
they are seeking the order against may commit one or more of the
acts. An attorney is needed
to present this complaint to the circuit court. The request must
state specific incidents of
assaults/ and/or threats, and may describe injuries sustained and
names of witnesses.
Personal protection orders (pursuant to MCLA 600.2950) are for
domestic violence victims only.
A relationship must exist between the victim or the perpetrator.
They must be: married, formerly
married, residing together, formerly residing together, have a child
in common 7/1/94, or have a
dating or formerly dating relationship 4/1/95.
Personal protection orders can prohibit the assailant from:
assaulting, beating, molesting or wounding
entering on to the premises removing minor children from the
individual having legal custody
threatening to kill or physically injure a named person (7/1/94)
interfering with the victim at her
place of employment 4/1/95 engaging in conduct which impairs the
victim's employment relationship
or environment 4/1/95 any other specific act that imposes a
restraint upon the victim's personal liberty
or causes a reasonable apprehension of violence. 4/1/95 (not until
4/1/96) Purchasing or possessing a
firearm.
Stalking language (MCLA 600.2450A) can be added to personal
protection orders that restrains the
assailant from: following or appearing within the sight of the
victim approaching or confronting the
victim in a public place or private property approaching at the
victim's home, work or school entering
onto or remaining on property owned, leased or occupied by the
victim contacting the victim by
telephone, mail or electronic mail placing an object on or
delivering an object to property owned,
leased, or occupied by the victim. The circuit court judge decides
whether to issue a personal protection order. If the judge does not,
s/he must immediately state in writing and on the record the reasons
for
so refusing. Victim may keep her address confidential. The order
goes into effect immediately after the
judge signs it. Service may be by registered mail. The assailant has
an opportunity to object and to
appear for a hearing. Police may arrest without a warrant when an
assailant violates a personal
protection order. A "show cause" hearing is held. If the assailant
is found by the judge to have violated
the order of the court, the assailant could be sentenced to up to 93
days in jail and receive a $500 fine
or both.
2. CRIMES A DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ASSAILANT MAY HAVE COMMITTED AND
COULD BE CHARGED
WITH IN THE STATE OF MICHIGAN.
A. ASSAULT AND BATTERY [MCLA 750.81]
Michigan Law defines a criminal assault and battery as an attempt or
offer to do bodily injury with a
present intention and ability to do so. See above. Assault is an
attempt or threat, with unlawful force,
to inflict bodily injury upon another, accompanied by the apparent
present ability to carry out the intent
if not deterred by another. A threat coupled with present ability
may be considered an assault. Battery
is the actual physical harm.
B. AGGRAVATED ASSAULT/ASSAULT AND INFLICTION OF SERIOUS
INJURY. [MCLA 750.81a]
Any person who shall assault another without any weapon and inflict
serious or aggravated injury upon
the person of another without intending to commit the crime of
murder and without intending to inflict
great bodily harm less than the crime of murder, shall be guilty of
a high misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in the county jail or
the state prison for a period of not more than one year or a fine
of
$500 or both.
C. FELONIOUS ASSAULT [MCLA 750.82]
A felonious assault is an assault with a dangerous weapon without an
intent to inflict great bodily harm.
Any person who shall assault another with a gun, revolver, pistol,
knife, iron bar, club, brass knuckles,
or other dangerous weapon, but without intending to commit the crime
of murder, and without intending
to inflict great bodily harm less than the crime of murder, shall be
guilty of a felonious assault.
D. ASSAULT WITH INTENT TO DO GREAT BODILY HARM LESS THAN
MURDER. Felony [MCLA 750.84]
Any person who shall assault another with intent to do great bodily
harm less than the crime of murder,
shall be guilty of a felony, punishable by imprisonment in the state
prison, not more than ten years, or by a fine of not more than
$5,000.
E. ASSAULT WITH INTENT TO MAIM. Felony [MCLA 750.86]
Any person who shall assault another with intent to maim or
disfigure his person by cutting out or
maiming the tongue, putting out or destroying an eye, cutting or
tearing off an ear, cutting or slitting
or mutilating the nose or lips or cutting off or disabling a limb,
organ, or member, shall be guilty of a
felony, punishable by imprisonment in the state prison not more than
ten years or by fine of not more
than $5,000.
F. ASSAULT WITH INTENT TO COMMIT MURDER. Felony [MCLA 750.83]
Any person who shall assault another with intent to commit the crime
of murder, shall be guilty of a
felony, punishable by imprisonment in the state prison for life or
any number of years.
G. CRIMINAL SEXUAL CONDUCT. {MCLA 750.520}
There are four degrees of criminal sexual conduct (usually known as
rape). First, second, and third
degrees are felonies. Fourth degree is a misdemeanor.
First and third degrees involve forced or coerced penetration.
This can involve vaginal intercourse,
anal or oral intercourse, or putting a finger or object in another
person's genital or anal opening.
Second and fourth degree involve forced or coerced sexual
contact. This includes touching the groin,
genital area, inner thigh, buttocks, or breasts, or the clothing
covering those parts.
How serious the crime is depends on a number of factors such as:
more than one rapist; a weapon; a
physical injury other than the rape; extortion;, or the element of
surprise. If the victim is under 13,
from 13 - 15 and the rapist is a member of the family or in a
position of authority, this also makes the
crime more serious. Criminal sexual conduct does not require a
witness other than the survivor. It is a
crime if the rapist is your spouse.
H. Malicious destruction of property [MCLA 750.377(a)]
I. Home Invasion, 3rd Degree. [MCLA 750.110(4)
If a person enters a house of another in violation of an existing
court order or with the intent to or
committing an assault therein, they have committed a felony.
J. Assault with intent to commit a felony [MCLA 750.87]
K. STALKING LAWS (See below)
SUMMARY OF LAWS APPLICABLE TO DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
A. ARREST WITHOUT A WARRANT; ASSAULT AND BATTERY OR INFLICTION
OF SERIOUS INJURY
WITHIN HOUSEHOLD [MCLA 764.15a (1980)].
This law is commonly known as the domestic violence warrantless
arrest statute. It allows the police
officer to make an arrest if the officer has "reasonable cause" to
believe that an assault has taken place, or is taking place, and
that the person who committed the violation is a spouse, former
spouse, or a person
who resides or who has resided in the same household as the victim,
or has a child in common with the
victim. Under these circumstances, the officer may arrest the
suspect without a warrant, whether the violation was committed in
the presence of the officer or not.
B. ARREST WITHOUT A WARRANT FOR INJUNCTIVE ORDER VIOLATIONS. [MCLA
764.15b (1983)].
This statute gives police officers the authority to arrest and take
into custody a person when the officer
has reasonable cause to believe that there is a valid domestic
assault restraining order with criminal
penalties filed properly.
C. DOMESTIC DISPUTE VICTIMS; ADVISING OF AVAILABILITY OF
SHELTER PROGRAM OR OTHER COMMUNITY SERVICES; NOTICE STATEMENT. [MCLA
764.15C (1985)]
After intervening in a domestic dispute, police officers are
required by law to provide the victim with information on the
availability of any local shelter program or other community
services, and their phone numbers. A written notification of these
services is to be given to the victim.
D. Amendment to the interim bond statute {Public Act 308,
formerly Senate Bill 583 (1990)
MCLA 750.582.} This bill was effective March 28th, 1991.
This law says that after a domestic assailant is arrested, he will
be held until the next session of court
where he will be arraigned. The only exception is if an arraignment
could not take place within 24 hours.
In that case, he will be released on interim bond after being held
for 20 hours.
E. Court Ordered Counseling Option for Assault Violations {MCLA
769.4A (1978)}
This law states that a person who pleads guilty or is convicted of
assault, or assault and battery may
be ordered by the court to participate in a mandatory counseling
program as a condition of probation.
F. Crime Victim's Rights Act {MCLA 780.751 (1985)}
This law establishes protections and rights that allow the victims
of certain crimes committed in Michigan
to be active participants in the criminal justice process. The law
defines a victim as: an individual who
suffers direct or threatened physical, financial, or emotional harm
as the result of the commission of a
crime. Crimes covered by the act include felonies and high
misdemeanors.
G. Compensation for Injured Crime Victims {MCLA 18.351
(1976)}.
Victims of certain personal injury crimes may receive financial
compensation for particular losses that
resulted from the crime.
H. Victims Seeking Help Assured of Confidentiality {MCLA
600.101 (1985)}
Victims of sexual assault and domestic violence who seek the
services of workers at sexual assault or domestic violence crisis
centers have the protection of law that the counseling sessions are
confidential
and not admissible in the court without the victim's written
consent.
I. The Ann Arbor Mandatory Arrest Ordinance.
There is an ordinance in Ann Arbor which states the police officers
are required to arrest domestic
assailants if they have reasonable cause to believe an assault took
place and there are visible signs
of injury or a threat with a weapon. This ordinance also requires
police to call the SAFE House on-call
team so that they can go to help the survivor of the assault. It
requires them to call the survivor to
let her know when the assailant will be released from jail.
J. Amendment to the Criminal Sexual Conduct Statute {MCLA
750.520} making spousal rape
a crime. {Public Act 138 of 1988}
A spouse can be charged with rape of his partner in Michigan.
K. STALKING LAWS
As of January 1, 1993, stalking is a crime in Michigan. Under the
new laws created, a victim may press charges against stalker, obtain
a restraining order with provisions for immediate arrest and
criminal
contempt penalties, and sue for actual and exemplary damages caused
by the stalker. These new laws
allow punishment for what was previously legal, though despicable,
behavior. Police, prosecutors, and
judges have been given the tools necessary to afford victims greater
protection from assailants.
However, since the laws are so new, we have little information on
how they will be applied in practice.
If you are being stalked by your assailant, call the police. We also
strongly encourage you to contact
an advocate at the domestic violence project for further assistance.
1. Stalking - MCLA 750.411h
Stalking is defined as a willful course of conduct involving
repeated or continuing harassment of another individual that would
cause a reasonable person to feel terrorized, frightened,
intimidated, threatened, harassed or molested, and that actually
causes the victim to feel terrorized, frightened, intimidated,
threatened, harassed, or molested. Behavior such as following you,
showing up at your home or at work, confronting you in public or in
private, making unwanted calls or sending unwanted letters, or
leaving
objects or "presents" for you at home, work, on/in your car or other
property can be used as evidence
of stalking. Stalking is a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment
of up to one year and/or a fine of up
to $1,000. In addition to incarceration and fines, an individual
found guilty of stalking may also be put
on probation for up to five years. The terms of probation may
include an anti-stalking order, a no
contact order, and/or mandatory counseling for the assailant, at his
own expense.
2. Aggravated Stalking - MCLA 750.411i
An individual who engages in stalking is guilty of aggravated
stalking if his actions include one or more
of the following: making a credible threat of injury to the victim
or a member of the victim's family or household; violating a
domestic assault or anti-stalking restraining order; violating a
condition of bond, pre-trial release or probation arising from a
stalking charge; or having a previous conviction for stalking
or aggravated stalking. Aggravated stalking is a felony, punishable
by imprisonment of up to five years,
and/or a fine of up to $5,000. In addition to incarceration and
fines, probation may be ordered for any
number of years, but not less than five years. The terms of
probation may include an anti-stalking order,
a no contact order, and/or mandatory counseling for the stalker, at
his own expense.
3. Anti-Stalking Restraining Orders - MCLA 600.2950a, MCLA
764.15b
A victim of stalking may petition the court for a restraining order
to prohibit stalking behaviors. The order must be specific as to the
particular behaviors to be restrained, but may include (though not
be limited
to): Following or appearing within the sight of the victim,
Approaching or confronting the victim in a
public place or on private property; Appearing at the victim's home,
work, or school; Entering onto or remaining on property owned,
leased, or occupied by the victim; Contacting the victim by
telephone,
mail or electronic mail;and Placing an object on or delivering an
object to property owned, leased, or
occupied by the victim. Violation of a valid anti-stalking
restraining order is punishable by immediate
arrest and the criminal contempt powers of the court. If found
guilty of criminal contempt, the stalker
may be sentenced to up to 90 days in jail and/or fined up to
$500.00. An individual who violates an anti-stalking order may also
be prosecuted and convicted of aggravated stalking for the same
violation. [MCLA 750.411i(6)]
4. Civil Suits for Damages Caused by Stalker - MCLA
600.2954(1)
A victim may sue the stalker for actual costs incurred as a result
of stalking (i.e. property damage, lost wages, medical/therapy
costs, etc.), exemplary damages, court costs and reasonable attorney
fees. A lawsuit may be bought regardless of whether or not the
stalker has been charged or convicted in a
criminal case.
K. PUBLIC ACT 52 OF 1993. EFFECTIVE 7/1/93.
Amends the Code of Criminal Procedure to allow police to make a
warrantless arrest if they have
reasonable cause to believe that a defendant has violated a
court-ordered protective condition of
release.
L. PUBLIC ACT 53 OF 1993. EFFECTIVE 7/1/93
Amends the Code of Criminal Procedure to require that court-ordered
protective conditions of release
be entered into the Law Enforcement Information Network (L.E.I.N.)
M. HB 4064. EFFECTIVE 11/28/93
Amends the Child Custody Act to include domestic violence as one of
the factors that judges must
consider when determining the best interests of the child for
purposes of making child custody decisions.
The factor reads: "Domestic violence, regardless of whether the
violence was directed against or
witnessed by the child."
N. HB 4308 - P.A. 68 of 1994. Effective 7-1-94.
Amends the Code of Criminal Procedure to reduce from two to one the
number of times a defendant
may have a domestic assault conviction deferred and dismissed upon
successful completion of probation.
Both the defendant and the prosecutor must consent to the placement
of the defendant on a deferred sentence. Requires the court to check
the defendant's record prior to deferring the proceedings.
Requires the court to enter an adjudication of guilt and proceed
with sentencing if the defendant
re-assaults the victim, violates a no contact order, or violates an
order for counseling.
O. HB 4325 - P.A. 65 OF 1994. Effective 7-1-94
Amends the Penal Code to increase the penalty for repeat domestic
assaults. Allows a third offense
that would normally be charged as assault or assault and battery (90
days and/or $100) to be elevated
to a to a felony (maximum penalty of 2 years and/or $1,000). {See
Senate Bill 326 for second offense language)
P. HB 4357 - P.A. 57 OF 1994. Effective 7-1-94.
Amends the Divorce Act provisions for domestic abuse injunctive
orders by adding "threatening to kill or physically injure a named
person" to the behaviors that can be prohibited and are punishable
by criminal contempt penalties.
Q. HB 4358 - P.A. 62 of 1994. Effective 7-1-94.
Amends the Code of Criminal Procedure to clarify that the prosecutor
shall prosecute criminal contempt proceedings initiated by the court
in response to an alleged violation of a domestic abuse injunctive
order
or an anti-stalking injunctive order, unless the victim chooses to
retain private counsel for the criminal contempt proceeding.
R. HB 4359 - P.A. 58 of 1994. Effective 7-1-94.
Amends the Revised Judicature Act provisions for domestic abuse
injunctive orders by adding
"threatening to kill or physically injure a named person" to the
behaviors that can be prohibited and are punishable by criminal
contempt penalties.
S. HB 4360 - P.A. 69 of 1994. Effective 7-1-94.
Amends the Code of Criminal Procedure by requiring police agencies
to establish written policies regarding their response to domestic
violence by January 1, 1995. Policy requirements include an emphasis
on
arrest as the preferred response upon a finding of probable cause
that a crime was committed in a
domestic situation. Provisions for insuring victim safety and
assistance are also required.
T. HB 4361 - P.A. 70 OF 1994. Effective 7-1-94.
Amends the Code of Criminal Procedure to prohibit a magistrate from
refusing to accept a domestic
assault complaint signed on information and belief by a person other
than the victim.
U. HB 4362 - P.A. 59 OF 1994. Effective 7-1-94.
Amends the Code of Criminal Procedure by adding "threatening to kill
or physically injure a named
individual" to the grounds for warrantless arrest on a violation of
a domestic abuse injunctive order, if the order contains such a
prohibition.
V. HB 4397 - P.A. 60 OF 1994. Effective 7-1-94.
Amends the Code of Criminal Procedure regarding the information
sheet given to victims of domestic
assault by adding that the victim may obtain an injunctive order
"restraining or enjoining the abuser from threatening to kill or
physically injure you".
W. SB 326 - P.A. 64 OF 1994. Effective 7-1-94.
Amends the Penal Code to increase the penalty for repeat domestic
assaults. Allows a second offense
that would normally be charged as assault or assault and battery (90
days and/or $100) to be elevated
to a one year misdemeanor ( maximum penalty of 1 year and /or $500).
Increases penalty for assault
and battering if a domestic relationship exists (current or former
spouse, resides or formerly resides,
child in common) to 93 days to trigger fingerprinting and CCH
reporting.
X. SB 587 - P.A. 63 OF 1994. Effective 7-1-94.
Amends the Code of Criminal Procedure to require police officers to
make a written report, including
standard basic information, in response to all domestic violence
calls, requires that such reports are
submitted to the prosecutors office for review. Also revises the
domestic violence victims rights notice
to include information about the police response and clearer
direction toward victim rights and referrals. Repeals the statue
that formerly required the court to dismiss a case without
prosecutor's consent if the victim stated s/he had received civil
satisfaction.
Y. SB 813 - P.A. 66 OF 1994. Effective 7-1-94.
Amends the Code of Criminal Procedure to allow warrantless arrest
for misdemeanor assaults not
witnessed by the police if the parties have a child in common.
Y. SB 1022 - P.A. 61 OF 1994. Effective 7-1-94.
Amends the Revised Judicature Act to require the court to enter a
domestic abuse injunctive order under certain circumstances, require
the State Court Administrative Office to develop and make available
free pro se domestic abuse injunctive order forms by October 1,
1994, and specifies in statute that
domestic abuse injunctive orders can be served by registered or
certified mail.
Z. HB 4515
Amends the Code of Criminal Procedure to improve procedures for
issuance and enforcement of peace
bonds. Increases from two years to five years the length of time
that a peace bond may remain in effect.
Compiled by Kathleen Hagenian and Susan McGee, Executive Director of
The Domestic Violence Project, Inc./SAFE House